Go to content

Review of Alias Grace - The British Empire

British Empire
1815-1914
Skip menu
Skip menu
Alias Grace
by Margaret Attwood
Alias Grace is a historical novel set in the Canada of the mid-c19th. It was first published in 1996 and won the Canadian Giller Prize and was shortlisted for the Booker Prize. It is based on the story of the murders of Thomas Kinnear and his housekeeper Nancy Montgomery in Upper Canada and the conviction of Grace Marks and James McDermott for those murders. Marks was sentenced to life imprisonment and much of the story is based on the interaction between Grace and Dr Simon Jordan, who researches her case and interviews Grace whilst she is in an asylum.

Dr Jordan is an up and coming doctor in the field of mental health and an expert on amnesia. He listens intently to Grace’s story of her life from her time in Ireland, the passage of the family to Canada and the tale of her time in service.

The book gives us an insight into the difficulties of an immigrant family arriving in the young town of Toronto and the conditions of prison and asylum life. It also makes reference to the rebellion in Toronto in 1837 and the causes for that rebellion. The rebellion had taken place six years before the murders of Montgomery and Kinnear but given the way the rebellion polarised Canadian society, it was to be remembered for many years. It took time for the upper classes to accept that it was possible for  the lower classes to be socially mobile and that the social hierarchies were not rigid.

Not only does this novel give us an insight into the Canada of the mid-c19th but it also offers the reader a glimpse into Victorian thought on mental  health, the study of which was in its infancy. It was taught in European universities where it was advocated that inmates be treated as patients rather than as prisoners. Victorians were very interested in the paranormal, the supernormal and the occult, and hypnotism and spiritualism were regarded as acceptable areas of study.
Back to content