Brighton and the Slave Trade
Claims made by University Lecturers and local councillors
Introduction
A couple of years ago I was watching the TV programme Question Time late one Thursday night. During the programme, the MP Jacob Rees-Mogg made the statement that the British concentration camps in the Boer War were there for the benefit and welfare of the Boer people. I couldn’t believe what I was hearing. I have studied the Boer War, written a number of essays on the war, given talks on the subject and visited the battlefields of the Second Anglo-Boer War 1899-1902, as well as visiting the memorials in Bloemfontein to the civilians who died in the British camps. Over 25,000 Boers, mainly women and children, died in the British concentration camps set up in late 1900 to deal with those who had been made homeless by the British burning their homes. Almost the same number of blacks died in separate concentration camps from the overcrowding, insanitary conditions, an insufficient diet, and inadequate planning. Jacob Rees-Mogg was not challenged during the programme and, to most viewers, what he said must have seemed to be the historical truth.
Rarely nowadays do we have historians on such programmes and with fewer and fewer students doing history at school and in their further education, our understanding of the past is poor. Historical truth has become a casualty of a world dominated by social media and TV channels seeing sensational stories. The recent election campaign in the USA has highlighted what former President Obama has referred to as ‘truth decay’.
When I heard claims made by Brighton councillors about how the historical development of Brighton & Hove was dependant on money earnt by the Slave Trade, I was concerned that these claims were being made to support their own political agenda, irrespective of what had actually happened in the past.
Comments welcome. Please use the Contact Form
Since 2007, the narrative about the slave trade and its impact on Britain has changed, and as a nation we are beginning to look at the British Empire in different ways. I myself have developed a website on the British Empire (www.britishempire.me.uk) in order to raise our understanding of the British Empire, warts and all, and have produced a number of items on Britain and the Slave Trade.
As a student of local and British imperial history, I knew nothing of the claims being made about Brighton’s past and decided to examine the evidence that was available to me. The claims made by councillors came during the ‘lockdown’ and I was only able to use those sources I had in my possession. I was not able to access rate books, census returns and trade directories, and what follows comes with the caveat that there might exist evidence to contradict my findings. I later discovered that a team from the University of Brighton was the source for what councillors were saying and although I have asked for the evidence for what they are saying, the University team has as yet failed to provide me with evidence to support the as yet unsubstantiated claims they and local councillors have made.
Claims made by Brighton & Hove councillors and University of Brighton lecturers
On May 21, 2018, Cathy Bergin and Anita Rupprecht, lecturers in the University of Brighton’s School of Humanities, published an article entitled Reparative histories: tracing narratives of black resistance and white entitlement in the journal Race and Class. In that article there is a section on Tracing racialised pasts in a coastal British city. The city is Brighton and Hove[1] and in that section are a number of claims about the historical development of Brighton which I contest. The claims are that a) a significant number of awardees of slave compensation lived in, or owned properties in, Brighton; b) many of whom invested in the new luxury housing developments springing up along the seafront to the east; c) colonial wealth extracted from the other side of the Atlantic, which also congealed in the city’s brick and flint; and d) in the short half mile along the sea-front, running east towards the grandeur of Thomas Kemp’s Sussex Square, records show eight properties occupied by recipients of very substantial slave compensation monies.
The assertion that 19th century Brighton was developed with the use of money from the slave trade and in particular from monies paid out as part of the slave compensation of the 1830s is one that I have asked the authors of the above article to substantiate. I have asked for examples of buildings built with ‘slave money’ and also for names of those people responsible for such housing developments. I have yet to see any evidence provided by them to substantiate the claims made.
On 23 January 2019, an item appeared on the University of Brighton website in response to media interest in the article Reparative histories. It was titled ‘Tracing Brighton’s forgotten slave-owners’ and stated that “Sixty-nine slave-owners and former slave-owners had a property in Brighton or Hove in the 19th century and concluded, “The violent sources of the colonial wealth that helped to build Brighton, however, is more difficult to represent.”
On June 12, 2020, a piece was posted on the Brighton & Hove Council website under the title ‘Community and Equalities’ saying: we must recognise that, as a Georgian town, our wealth is built on the sugar trade and enslavement”. The piece went on the say that the Council would “review all plaques, monuments, statues and street names on public land to ensure they celebrate legacies which reflect the city’s values” and “that we must acknowledge the contribution the sugar trade played in the growth of the city”. No evidence was offered for what was said about the historical development of Brighton & Hove.
A couple of weeks later, on 23 June, the then Council Leader, Nancy Platts, said in an article in the Argus that “It is important that we reflect on Brighton and Hove’s Georgian history which meant much of the investment that led to its growth came from Caribbean sugar plantations and the enslavement of people.” Nancy Platts went on to say in the same article that “It is troubling that many of the city’s buildings exist because of that brutal trade and 69 slave-owners and former slave owners had a Brighton or Hove address between 1800 and 1880. Most of them - unlike the freed slaves received substantial financial compensation on abolition of slavery in the 1830s.”
I asked Nancy Platts for the source of her information and she told me in an email that it was the University of Brighton. I assume she was referring to the press release issued on 23 January 2019.
Subsequently (on 27 July 2020), I wrote to Dr Bergin, one of the authors of Reparative Histories, providing details of my analysis of those people who, according to the LBS[2] database, have links with Brighton and Hove, and asked for details to substantiate what had been said in her article and in the press release. In particular I asked her to identify buildings which had been built with money earnt from the sugar trade and to provide evidence of links between the developers of Georgian Brighton and the slave trade. I received a reply on 10 September from Anita Rupprecht and Gillian Scott (another member of the research team) which offered no evidence for what had been said, either in the press release of 23 January or the article authored by Cathy Bergin and Anita Rupprecht.
Given the complete lack of evidence provided by the University team, I decided to embark on my own analysis of connections between those with Brighton and Hove links on the LBS website to the historical development of Brighton.
[1] Brighton and Hove were separate civil parishes until on April 1 1997 the two Boroughs of Brighton and Hove were combined to form the unitary area of Brighton & Hove. Brighton had become a borough on April 1 1854 and Hove in 1898. The main focus in this study is Brighton however the Brunswick development was in Hove
[2] The Centre for the Study of the Legacies of British Slave-ownership was established at the University of London (UCL) in 2009 and has produced a database of the records of the Slave Compensation Commission (SCC), called Legacies of British Slave Ownership (LBS)